How to Know You’ve Found the Right Psychologist: 10 Signs Therapy Is Working
Unsure if therapy is working?
You’ve taken the brave step of reaching out for support and attended your first few sessions with a psychologist.
But now you might be wondering:
- Is this what therapy is supposed to feel like?
- How do I know if this psychologist is right for me?
- Should I already be feeling better?
- What if therapy isn’t working?
These questions are incredibly common.
Unfortunately, many people have experiences with psychologists that feel underwhelming.
Perhaps you’ve found yourself thinking:
“She was lovely to talk to, but nothing really changed.”
“I was given lots of strategies, but they didn’t work for me.”
“We just talked every week and I wasn’t sure where therapy was heading.”
Experiences like these can leave people feeling disappointed and questioning whether therapy works.
The good news is that psychological therapy is highly effective and supported by decades of research. More often than not, when therapy doesn’t feel helpful, it doesn’t mean therapy doesn’t work. It usually means one of two things:
- The psychologist may not be the right fit for you.
- The approach being used may not be the right approach for your needs.
The right psychologist should help you feel understood, supported and hopeful about positive change.
Why Finding the Right Psychologist Matters
Therapy is unlike most other healthcare appointments.
You may talk about things that feel vulnerable, painful or deeply personal. Because of this, the relationship you develop with your psychologist is incredibly important.
You are also investing your time, emotional energy and money into therapy, so it should feel worthwhile.
Research consistently shows that one of the strongest predictors of successful therapy is something called the therapeutic alliance – the quality of the relationship between the psychologist and client.
In simple terms:
The better the relationship, the better the outcomes.
10 Signs You’ve Found the Right Psychologist
1. You Feel Comfortable Talking Openly
It’s completely normal to feel nervous at first. However, over time you should generally feel safe enough to share things that matter to you.
You don’t need to tell your psychologist everything immediately, but you should feel increasingly comfortable bringing your thoughts, emotions and experiences into the room.
2. You Feel Understood
One of the most powerful experiences in therapy is feeling genuinely understood.
A good psychologist doesn’t simply hear your story. They make sense of your experiences and reflect them back in a way that makes you feel:
“I feel like they really get me.”
Feeling understood often brings enormous relief because you no longer feel alone in your struggles.
3. You Don’t Feel Judged
Psychologists are trained to approach people with curiosity, compassion and understanding.
Even when discussing difficult experiences, mistakes or behaviours you’re not proud of, you should generally feel accepted rather than judged.
4. You Feel Hopeful
Even after discussing painful issues, many people leave therapy feeling slightly lighter and more hopeful.
You may not have solved your problems after one session, but you should feel:
“Maybe things can get better.”
Hope is incredibly important because it motivates us to continue making changes.
5. You Have a Shared Direction
Therapy shouldn’t feel like endless conversations with no purpose.
You and your psychologist should gradually develop a shared understanding of:
- What is causing your distress
- What you would like to improve
- What progress may look like
This doesn’t need to be a rigid treatment plan, but there should be a sense that you’re working towards something together.
6. You Feel Like You’re Working as a Team
The best therapy relationships feel collaborative.
Rather than feeling like your psychologist has their own agenda, therapy should feel like you’re working side-by-side towards shared goals.
You should feel included in the process rather than directed by it.
7. You’re Gaining New Insights
Good therapy often helps you see yourself and your experiences differently.
You may find yourself having “ah-ha” moments where things suddenly make more sense. These insights often become important turning points in therapy.
8. You Notice Small Changes in Your Wellbeing
Positive change doesn’t always look dramatic.
You may notice:
- You’re worrying slightly less.
- You’re sleeping better.
- You’re feeling calmer.
- You’re crying less often.
- You’re communicating differently.
- You’re feeling more confident.
- You’re coping better with challenges.
Small shifts often become meaningful changes over time.
9. You Feel Genuinely Cared For
Warmth matters. A good psychologist should feel kind, genuine and caring.
You should feel that your psychologist is invested in understanding your experience and helping you move towards a better place.
10. You Trust the Process
Perhaps the biggest sign that you’ve found the right psychologist is that you trust the process.
Even when therapy feels difficult, you believe:
“I think this person can help me.”
And:
“I think things can get better.”
That sense of trust is often what allows meaningful change to occur.
Why Therapy Sometimes Doesn’t Feel Helpful
Sometimes therapy isn’t working as well as it could.
There are several common reasons:
- The psychologist may not have experience with your specific difficulties.
- The approach may not suit your needs.
- Your personalities or communication styles may not fit well.
- The psychologist may not be building enough understanding, warmth or connection.
- Therapy may feel generic rather than tailored to you.
None of these experiences mean therapy doesn’t work. They usually indicate that something in the therapeutic relationship or approach needs adjusting.
What Should You Do If Something Feels Missing?
If your psychologist feels reasonably good but something isn’t quite clicking, try talking openly about your experience.
Psychologists are familiar with receiving feedback and should respond by exploring your concerns and adapting their approach where possible.
You might say:
“I don’t feel like we’ve got a clear direction yet.”
“I don’t feel fully understood.”
“I think I need something different from our sessions.”
Sometimes these conversations significantly improve therapy. However, sometimes another psychologist may simply be a better fit.
Finding the right psychologist can be a little like trying on shoes. You may need to try a few before you find the perfect fit.
How Peaceful Mind Psychology Helps Clients Find the Right Fit
At Peaceful Mind Psychology, we understand that finding the right psychologist can sometimes feel overwhelming.
Our experienced support team takes the time to understand your concerns, goals and preferences before thoughtfully matching you with a psychologist who suits both your needs and personality.
We also understand that occasionally the first psychologist may not feel like the perfect fit. If this happens, we are happy to discuss your experience confidentially and help you explore alternative options within our team or suggest alternative recommendations, such as the APS Find a Psychologist database.
Finding the right psychologist can be life changing, and we believe everyone deserves to feel understood, supported and hopeful in therapy.
~
If you’re working well with your psychologist, you may like to learn more on some Tips and Strategies for Getting the Most Out of Your Psychology Sessions.